Skip to content
Yep AI
BlogCustomer Service

Holiday Returns on Shopify: A Checklist to Get Your Inbox Ready for January

Most store owners plan carefully for the sales rush and then get caught out by what follows. Holiday returns arrive as a flood of messages, all at once, while you are tired.

By Yep AI Editorial TeamUpdated 5 min read

Holiday Returns on Shopify: A Checklist to Get Your Inbox Ready for January
On this page
  1. Why Holiday Returns Hit Hard in January
  2. The Three Types of Return Messages
  3. Your Pre January Checklist
  4. Reduce Ecommerce Returns Before They Happen
  5. Where Yep AI Fits
  6. Get Ready for Holiday Returns With Yep AI

Most store owners plan carefully for the sales rush and then get caught out by what follows. Holiday returns arrive as a flood of messages, all at once, while you are tired. This checklist helps you set things up before they land, so January feels manageable.

Why Holiday Returns Hit Hard in January

The numbers explain it. The US National Retail Federation reported that retailers expected 17% of holiday sales to be returned, and 19.3% of online sales across 2025. Online stores tend to see more, partly because shoppers cannot try things on first.

Gifts add to it. People receive the wrong size, a duplicate or something they simply do not want, and they write to the store after the holidays. Each of those is a message for you to answer.

The Three Types of Return Messages

Almost every return message is one of three kinds. Planning for each makes the inbox far easier.

1. “How do I return this?” This is the most common. A clear policy and a ready reply solve it. Put the steps in your order emails and on a returns page, and many shoppers will not need to ask.

2. “Where is my refund or exchange?” These are status questions. Customers worry when they hear nothing, so a short update at each stage cuts the follow up messages.

3. “Can you make an exception?” Outside the window, no packaging, or arrived damaged. These need your judgement, so decide in advance which ones you will approve without a second look.

Your Pre January Checklist

Work through these in order. Most take under an hour.

  1. Choose your holiday return window. Many stores extend it for gifts. Pick one end date and state it everywhere.
  2. Rewrite your return policy in plain language. Say what can be returned, how long customers have and who pays for postage.
  3. Add return steps to your emails. Include them in the order confirmation and shipping emails, with a link to your returns page.
  4. Write five reply templates. Cover how to start a return, refund timing, exchanges, outside the window and damaged items.
  5. Decide refund, exchange or store credit. Think about cash flow. Store credit keeps money in the business, but refunds build trust.
  6. Set your approval limit. Choose a refund amount you will approve without asking anyone.
  7. Block inbox time. Set aside 30 minutes a day for the first two weeks of January.
  8. Add returns to your FAQ page. Answer the top three questions there first.

Reduce Ecommerce Returns Before They Happen

You cannot stop every return, but you can prevent the avoidable ones. Many returns come from “it was not what I expected”, which is a product page problem.

Add sizing and fit details, show items from more than one angle, and state materials clearly. Answer pre sale questions quickly too, because a shopper who gets a clear answer before buying is less likely to send the item back.

Keep an eye on repeat patterns as well. The same NRF report found that 9% of returns are fraudulent. With a small store, one odd case is not a trend, but the same customer returning item after item deserves a closer look.

Where Yep AI Fits

Returns questions follow set patterns, which is what Yep AI’s support agent, Anna, is built for. Handling returns is one of her skills. She checks whether an item qualifies under your policy, starts exchanges, explains the next steps and answers order status questions at any hour, in more than 90 languages. She is part of the Growth plan.

Say a customer writes on December 27 to ask about returning a jumper in the wrong size. Anna checks the order, confirms it is inside your window and guides them through the exchange. If a refund is above the limit you set, she passes the conversation to you with the order details attached, so you do not start from scratch.

That is the approval limit from your checklist, working for you. For more detail, read about automating Shopify returns without losing the personal touch, how AI handles order tracking and the AI to human handoff guide. You can also see the ecommerce customer service solution.

Get Ready for Holiday Returns With Yep AI

You do not need a perfect system by January 1. Start with the checklist, write your templates and set your approval limit. Then let Yep AI handle the routine questions while you deal with the exceptions.

Install Yep AI from the Shopify App Store and start your 14 day free trial. Cancel anytime, with no lock in. Questions first? Talk to the team.

Yep AI is a Melbourne based platform that gives Shopify stores AI agents for support, sales and marketing.

Written by the Yep AI Editorial Team. Last updated .More Blog
FAQ

Common Questions,Answered Clearly.

When do holiday returns peak?

They build in the days after Christmas and stay high through January. Gift returns and exchanges make up much of it.

How long should a holiday return window be?

There is no single answer. Many stores extend the window for holiday orders. Choose an end date you can support and state it clearly.

Should I offer a refund or store credit?

Offer what suits your cash flow. Exchanges and store credit keep revenue in the business, while refunds build trust. You can also offer all three and let the customer choose.

How can I reduce holiday returns on Shopify?

Improve sizing guides, product photos and descriptions, and answer pre sale questions fast. These fix the “not what I expected” returns, which are the easiest to prevent.

Can AI handle returns for my Shopify store?

AI can handle the routine parts, such as checking eligibility, explaining steps and answering status questions. You set the rules and the refund limit, and anything above it goes to you.

Ready to Hire YourAI Agents?

Launch your AI workforce in minutes and let Yep AI handle customer support, sales, marketing, and daily operations while you focus on growing your business.

Set up in under 10 minutes · Cancel anytime

Book a call

Prefer to Talk It Through?Book a Time With Our Team.

See Yep AI working on a store like yours, ask about security and data isolation, and get a plan recommendation. Pick a time that suits you.

  • Video call
  • Your time zone

Choose a time

Pick a preferred day

Book a Call

You’ll confirm the exact time on the next screen.

Start 14-Day Free Trial

Set up in under 10 minutes · Cancel anytime