On this page
Most stores spend heavily to win a first order and very little on the customers who already know them. Yet a lapsed customer has already trusted you once. A short, well timed sequence can remind them you exist. Win back email automation Shopify owners set up once keeps doing that work in the background.
Who Counts as a Lapsed Customer?
There is no universal answer. Look at how often customers normally reorder, then pick a window that is clearly longer.
- A consumable product might lapse after 60 to 90 days.
- A seasonal or gift product might lapse after 9 to 12 months.
- A one time purchase may never lapse, so use a different approach.
Choose the window from your own order history rather than copying a number from somewhere else. Pull the gap between first and second orders for your repeat buyers, and use a point just beyond the typical gap. Anyone past that point has behaved differently from your usual repeat customer.
This kind of email marketing automation works because it runs on a trigger rather than a calendar. Instead of sending one big message to everyone each quarter, each customer enters the sequence on their own timeline.
Win Back Email Automation Shopify Stores Can Start With: Three Emails
- The check in. A friendly note, no discount. Remind them what they bought and what is new.
- The helpful follow up. Share a useful guide, a bestseller or a restock. Give them a reason to visit.
- The final nudge. Make a clear offer if it suits your margins, with an end date.
Subject lines matter as much as the body, because a lapsed customer decides in a second whether to open. Plain, specific lines usually beat clever ones. Keep each email short, with one link and one idea. Stop the sequence as soon as the customer buys or unsubscribes.
Win Back Checklist
☐ Segment customers by last order date.
☐ Exclude anyone with an open support issue or recent return.
☐ Write three emails in your brand voice.
☐ Space them several days apart.
☐ Add a clear unsubscribe link in every message.
☐ Track opens, clicks and orders for each email.
☐ Review and refresh the copy each quarter.
Understanding your retention numbers also helps. Our glossary entry on customer retention rate explains how to measure it.
Offer or No Offer?
- Approach
- No discount
- Pros
- Protects margin
- Cons
- May feel low urgency
- Approach
- Small, time limited offer
- Pros
- Gives a reason to act
- Cons
- Trains some customers to wait
- Approach
- Value led (guide, restock, new range)
- Pros
- Builds goodwill
- Cons
- Slower to show results
| Approach | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| No discount | Protects margin | May feel low urgency |
| Small, time limited offer | Gives a reason to act | Trains some customers to wait |
| Value led (guide, restock, new range) | Builds goodwill | Slower to show results |
A blend usually works: start with value, and keep any offer for the last email.
Keeping the Emails Fresh
If you have already written flows for welcome or post purchase messages, reuse their layout so the win back sequence feels like part of the same brand. For ideas on how multi channel content can reuse one product story, see our post on running a multi channel campaign from one product. Win back emails often fail because they sound generic. Use real product names, mention what changed since their last visit, and keep the tone consistent with the rest of your brand. Drafting three versions for different customer groups is more effort than most teams can sustain by hand, which is where automation helps.
Where Yep AI Fits
Maya is Yep AI's Marketing agent. She drafts email journeys for Klaviyo or Mailchimp, using the brand voice settings you set. You review everything in the Marketing Hub before it goes out, so the final say stays with you. Read more in introducing Maya and the guide to AI marketing for Shopify with automated content. See how marketing automation fits together on the ecommerce marketing solution page.
You can also compare plans on the pricing page.
Try It on Your Store
Put win back email automation Shopify stores rely on to work, without writing every email yourself. Install Yep AI from the Shopify App Store and start the 14-day free trial. Cancel anytime, no lock in. Questions? Book a call.
